- This topic has 4 replies, 4 voices, and was last updated 6 years, 9 months ago by
.
-
Posts
-
hi,
Can anyone direct me to a standard which would allow the welding of alloy steel such as AS1444-4140 to itself? This seems to be out of the scope of AS1554 parts 1 or 4. Can a procedure be qualified based on an 'unlisted' steel and use the carbon equivalence to assign a weldability group number?
thanks,
This is not unusual to come across this sort of situation
in cases like this you should consult the material manufacturers data sheet for their recommendations
You can qualify it to the likes of AS1554.1 in lieu of anything else just list the restriction on the WPS
I hope this helps
R
GFHi Flash,
Wouldn’t the clause 2.1 (a) from AS/NZS 1554 Part 1 (minimum yield strength not exceeding 500 mpa) stop you from using AS/NZS 1554 Part 1 ?
Regards,
BBHey BB
I am hearing you
but in the lieu of a recognised standard it is at least a recognised test method
as stated previously list it as a restriction on the WPSand the clause 1.3 Innovation, can be used as a basis for the decision
I agreed it is not a perfect situation
But As1554.1 not prequalified consumable and joint – testing covers most requirements
R
FlashThe clause 1.3 Innovation, can be used as a basis for the decision
I agreed it is not a perfect situation
But As1554.1 not prequalified consumable and joint – testing covers most requirements
R
FlashI agree with you Flash. First run it past the client and inspector and make sure they are happy
with it.
AS1444-4140 steel would have a max carbon equivalent of 0.925%, which gives a weldability group
number of 12. Use test methods for procedure qualification as though joint and consumables are
not pre-qualified. You would also want tensile test to fracture outside the weld zone, and above the
minimum tensile strength of the material.Here is what it says in clause 1.3 of AS1554.1
Any alternative materials, welding processes, consumables, methods of construction or
testing that give equivalent results to those specified, but do not comply with the specific
requirements of this Standard or are not mentioned in it, are not necessarily prohibited.
The Joint Standards Australia/Standards New Zealand Committee on welding of structures
can act in an advisory capacity concerning equivalent suitability, but specific approval
remains the prerogative of the inspecting authority.Hope this helps,
Regards,
Gary
- You must be logged in to reply to this topic.